Inheritance Tax Investigations Surge by 41% in 2024-25: A UK Compliance Crisis 📈

The UK inheritance tax landscape has shifted dramatically, with HMRC opening 3,961 investigations in 2024-25, up from 2,807 the previous year – a staggering 41% increase. This surge represents more than just numbers; it signals a fundamental change in how HMRC approaches inheritance tax compliance, affecting thousands of grieving families across the nation.

Bottom Line Up Front: Inheritance tax investigations have reached unprecedented levels, driven by frozen tax thresholds, enhanced HMRC detection methods, and upcoming pension reforms. Families must prioritise accurate record-keeping and consider professional guidance to navigate this evolving compliance landscape.

Why Are IHT Investigations Skyrocketing? 🔍

The dramatic increase in investigations stems from several converging factors that have created a perfect storm for inheritance tax scrutiny.

Frozen Thresholds Creating More Taxable Estates

The nil-rate band has been fixed at £325,000 since 2009/10 and will continue to be fixed until at least April 2028. Meanwhile, the average property price has increased by 87% since 2009, from £155,852 to £291,000 by August 2023. This means families who never considered themselves wealthy are increasingly caught in the inheritance tax net.

Simple Calculation Example:

• 2009 nil-rate band: £325,000
• 2009 average house price: £155,852
• 2023 average house price: £291,000
• If thresholds had kept pace with house prices: £607,750

The gap between static tax thresholds and rising asset values has created a revenue windfall for HMRC, with inheritance tax receipts reaching £8.2 billion in 2024/25, representing a 10.8% increase.

Enhanced HMRC Detection Capabilities

HMRC has significantly upgraded its investigation methods. The tax office now cross-references data from HM Land Registry and uses tools like Street View to verify property valuations. This technological approach allows investigators to identify discrepancies more efficiently than ever before.

Record Revenue Recovery

The financial incentive for investigations is clear. HMRC recovered £285m from inheritance tax investigations in the tax year ending 31 March 2024, representing a 14% increase from the previous year when £254m was collected. However, interestingly, only 45% of probes led to higher bills in the most recent year versus 65% previously, suggesting HMRC may be casting its net wider.

Who's Being Targeted? 🎯

High-Value Estate Focus

Estates with a total asset value of over £2m have been identified as those which will attract more scrutiny from a dedicated investigations team at HMRC. A dedicated team has even been set up to investigate individuals with an income above £200,000 or assets of over £2 million.

Common Investigation Triggers

HMRC investigations typically focus on several key areas:

Property Valuations: If a property is sold within two years of probate and it fetches a significantly higher price than the probate value, HMRC may decide to open an investigation.

Valuable Items: HMRC commonly asks for copies of home contents insurance and cross-references the insured items with the items submitted on the IHT return.

Seven-Year Gift Rule: Gifts made within seven years of death can have a significant bearing on the IHT payable, but it is often a difficult area for personal representatives to tackle.

The Upcoming Pension Bombshell 💣

From April 2027, the inheritance tax landscape will change dramatically. Most unused pension funds and death benefits will be included in the value of a person's estate for inheritance tax purposes from 6 April 2027.

Impact on Families

HMRC estimate that 38,500 estates will pay more IHT than before, with an average increase of £34,000 per affected estate. More concerning is the potential for double taxation: on death after the age of 75, there will be a 'double' tax charge on beneficiaries drawing down the pension: the IHT charge at 40% on the value of the pension pot and an income tax charge at the beneficiaries' marginal rate, potentially giving rise to a confiscatory effective tax rate of 67%.

Current Investigation Process and Timelines ⏰

How HMRC Conducts Investigations

When HMRC opens an investigation, the process typically follows these stages:

Initial Contact: HMRC will notify a taxpayer in writing when it commences to examine their tax affairs, typically sending a letter requesting more information.

Information Gathering: HMRC leaves no stone unturned in these investigations, analysing bank statements to identify income which may suggest the existence of undisclosed assets such as investments or property or significant foreign currency transactions.

Financial Consequences: The interest rate executors pay on overdue inheritance tax stands at 8.25%, which can add a significant amount to the bill.

Timeline Expectations

Investigations can take months and occasionally years to complete. HMRC aim to issue the IHT421 within 10 working days of receiving your IHT400 and/or payment of any Inheritance Tax due, but detailed checks can take up to 12 weeks.

Common Compliance Failures and How to Avoid Them ⚠️

Inadequate Record Keeping

In most probate matters, the deceased did not keep clear records of gifts made. This creates significant challenges for personal representatives trying to comply with the seven-year gift reporting requirements.

Best Practice: Maintain detailed records of all gifts over £250, including:

• Date of gift
• Recipient details
• Value at time of gift
• Source of funds
• Any conditions attached

Property Valuation Errors

A RICS valuation is generally a good idea rather than relying on estate agent appraisals. For valuable items, if there is any question as to whether an item might be of value (i.e. over £1,500), then the safest course of action is for that item to be individually valued by someone appropriately qualified.

Form Selection Mistakes

Many families use the wrong inheritance tax form. The IHT205 is suitable for simpler estates under certain thresholds, while IHT400 is required for more complex situations. IHT400 is mandatory for estates over £325,000, gifts within seven years exceeding annual exemptions, or estates involving trusts or complex assets.

Essential Forms and Procedures 📋

Key Inheritance Tax Forms

IHT205 - Short Form Return

• Purpose: Excepted estates under threshold
• When Required: Simple estates below £325,000
• Key Features: Simplified reporting process

IHT400 - Full Inheritance Tax Account

• Purpose: Comprehensive inheritance tax account
• When Required: Taxable or complex estates over £325,000
• Key Features: Detailed asset disclosure and tax calculations

IHT403 - Gifts and Transfers Schedule

• Purpose: Recording gifts and transfers
• When Required: Used with IHT400 for gifts within seven years
• Key Features: Seven-year gift reporting requirements

IHT30 - Clearance Certificate Application

• Purpose: Confirms all inheritance tax paid
• When Required: After estate administration complete
• Key Features: Final compliance confirmation from HMRC

Professional Support and When to Seek Help 🤝

Warning Signs You Need Professional Advice

Consider professional help if the estate involves:

• Assets worth over £2 million
• Substantial gifts made within seven years
• Business or agricultural property
• Overseas assets or non-UK domicile issues
• Complex trust structures
• Valuable art, antiques, or collections

For comprehensive estate planning and inheritance tax guidance, speak to our experienced tax specialists who can help navigate these complex requirements.

Protecting Personal Representatives

Personal representatives should take particular care when making distributions of estate assets if there is any possibility of a HMRC investigation being commenced, as there is a risk that they could find themselves personally liable for any shortfall.

Looking Ahead: Future Compliance Landscape 🔮

Additional Revenue Pressures

HMRC have announced that they will receive £69 million from the Government over the next five years to recruit more staff for tackling tax compliance, with a portion going towards compliance checking large estates.

Impact of Pension Reforms

The 2027 pension reforms represent the most significant change to inheritance tax in decades. The government estimates that, of around 213,000 estates with inheritable pension wealth in 2027 to 2028, 10,500 estates will have an inheritance tax liability where previously they would not.

Practical Steps for Families 💡

Immediate Actions

1. Review existing wills and estate plans
2. Gather and organise financial documentation
3. Consider professional valuations for significant assets
4. Maintain detailed gift records going forward
5. Review pension death benefit nominations

Long-term Planning

Consider strategies such as:

• Regular use of annual gift exemptions
• Establishing trusts for asset protection
• Utilising business and agricultural property reliefs
• Life insurance planning to cover potential tax liabilities

For personalised estate planning advice, contact our team to discuss your specific circumstances.

Key Takeaways for Executors and Families 📝

The 41% surge in inheritance tax investigations reflects HMRC's determination to maximise revenue from a system where thresholds haven't kept pace with asset values. Success in this environment requires meticulous record-keeping, accurate valuations, and often professional guidance.

Remember that keeping good records makes it easier for families to provide the information needed for the inheritance tax return and manage any potential compliance check. The cost of proper planning and professional advice is typically far less than the penalties, interest, and stress of a prolonged HMRC investigation.

The inheritance tax landscape will become even more complex from 2027, making proactive planning essential for all families with significant assets. For expert guidance on inheritance tax compliance and planning, explore our comprehensive accounting services designed to protect your family's financial future.

Frequently Asked Questions 🤔

Q: What triggers an HMRC inheritance tax investigation? A: Common triggers include estates over £2 million, property sales shortly after probate at significantly higher values than declared, discrepancies in asset valuations, substantial gifts within seven years of death, and complex financial arrangements involving trusts or overseas assets.

Q: How long do inheritance tax investigations typically take? A: Investigations can range from several months to years. HMRC aims to issue initial responses within 10 working days for straightforward cases, but detailed compliance checks can take up to 12 weeks, with complex investigations potentially lasting much longer.

Q: What are the financial consequences of errors in inheritance tax returns? A: Penalties can reach up to 100% of tax lost for deliberate errors, plus interest at 8.25% on overdue payments. Even innocent mistakes can result in significant additional costs, making accurate initial reporting crucial.

Q: When should I use form IHT400 instead of IHT205? A: Use IHT400 for estates worth over £325,000 after debts, any estate with gifts exceeding annual exemptions made within seven years of death, estates involving trusts or overseas assets, or those claiming business/agricultural property relief.

Q: How will the 2027 pension reforms affect inheritance tax planning? A: From April 2027, unused pension pots and most death benefits will be included in estates for inheritance tax purposes. This could create effective tax rates of up to 67% for post-75 deaths due to combined inheritance tax and income tax charges on beneficiaries.

---

Read more on our blog → https://bit.ly/41crAyQ

Book a Free Consultation → https://bit.ly/BookFreeConsultation15

Explore Our Services → https://bit.ly/maandco

MA & CO Podcast → https://bit.ly/4hZvqT3

---